Greenspoon Marder Client Alert: Where is the Injury and Where Does the TCPA Mention Texts? – Nowhere –

Aug 29, 2019 Fort Lauderdale, FL

By: Beth-Ann E. Krimsky, Esq. and Jamey R. Campellone, Esq.

On August 28, 2019, the Eleventh Circuit issued an opinion rejecting Article III standing in the context of a Telephone Consumer Protection Act (“TCPA”) action in Salcedo v. Hanna, No. 17-14077 (11^th Cir. Aug. 28, 2019). The time to file a petition for rehearing has not expired. The Eleventh Circuit’s most recent decision addressing the TCPA is likely to affect TCPA lawsuits nationwide that are based on allegations of receiving text messages. The Eleventh Circuit through the Honorable Judges Elizabeth Branch, Danny Reeves (sitting by designation from the E.D. Kentucky) and Jill Pryor (concurring in judgment) reversed the District Court and held a TCPA plaintiff who alleged receipt of one text message does not have Article III standing. Not only may this decision impact the pleading stage, but the class certification stage also is now poised to be more difficult for the plaintiffs’ bar to navigate as this holding opens the door to the need for individualized inquiries as to individual injury in every class action lawsuit involving text messages.

Recognizing the lack of mention of “text message” in the TCPA, the Court opined that the “receipt of a single text message is qualitatively different from the kinds of things Congress was concerned about when it enacted the TCPA.” As for the lack of standing based on a lack of injury, the Eleventh Circuit found that the specific harm allegedly suffered by Plaintiff Salcedo did not amount to a concrete harm that meets the injury-in-fact requirements of Article III. The Eleventh Circuit stated it “assessed how concrete and real the alleged harm is, Spokeo, 136 S. Ct. at 1548, and we have concluded that it is not the kind of harm that constitutes an injury in fact.”

In its opinion, the Eleventh Circuit confirmed “[t]he federal courts . . . have only the power ‘to say what the law is.’ Marbury v. Madison, 5 U.S. (1 Cranch) 137, 177 (1803). And when a plaintiff comes to us without alleging a concrete harm [i.e., only receiving one text message], a real injury that states a case or controversy, we cannot do even that much.”

The Appellate Court recognized its view is different from its sister circuit, when it concluded the Ninth Circuit’s decision in Van Patten v. Vertical Fitness Group, LLC, 847 F.3d 1037, 1043 (9th Cir. 2017), was not persuasive in the instant case. Thus, the Eleventh Circuit, while tempering the ability of those who seek to expand and exploit the TCPA to well beyond its intended application and purpose, has set the stage for a United States Supreme Court review.

About Greenspoon Marder

Greenspoon Marder LLP is a full-service law firm with over 225 attorneys and more than 20 office locations across the United States. With operations from Miami to New York and from Denver to Los Angeles, our firm attracts some of the nation’s top talent in key markets and innovation hubs. Our core practice areas include Real Estate, Litigation, and Transactional Services, complemented by the capabilities of a full-service firm. Greenspoon Marder has maintained a spot on The American Lawyer’s Am Law 200 as one of the top law firms in the U.S. since 2015, and our goal is to provide exceptional client service by developing a thorough understanding of each client’s business needs and objectives in order to provide strategic, cost-effective solutions.

MEDIA CONTACT

Natalie Villanueva, Director of Marketing
954.333.4308 | [email protected]

This Greenspoon Marder LLP Client Alert is issued for informational purposes only and is not intended to be construed or used as general legal advice nor a solicitation of any type. Please contact the author(s) or your Greenspoon Marder LLP contact if you have any questions regarding the currency of this information. The hiring of a lawyer is an important decision. Before you decide, ask for written information about the lawyer’s legal qualifications and experience.

Previous Next

News

Greenspoon Marder Client Alert: Where is the Injury and Where Does the TCPA Mention Texts? – Nowhere –

Share

News & Events

News & Events